How to Train Your Dog Using Meal Times Instead of Treats

Here’s something that bugs me. Walk into any pet store and you’ll find an entire aisle dedicated to training treats. Freeze-dried liver bites, salmon nibbles, “training-size” morsels that cost more per ounce than a decent steak. And the message is clear — if you want a well-trained dog, you need to keep buying these little bags of expensive motivation.

But here’s what I’ve learned after 15+ years of training dogs: your dog’s regular kibble is the most underused training tool in your kitchen. My Border Collie, Juno, learned her entire obedience repertoire using nothing but her daily meals split into training sessions. No special treats. No extra calories. Just her breakfast and dinner, delivered differently.

The idea isn’t new. Dr. Ian Dunbar has been telling puppy owners to ditch the food bowl for decades. Yet somehow, this advice gets buried under an avalanche of treat recommendations. If you want to train dog with food without treats — actual purchased training treats — this guide breaks down exactly how to do it. Your wallet and your dog’s waistline will both thank you.

Why Mealtime Training Works (Especially for Food-Motivated Dogs)

The Problem With Endless Training Treats

Let’s do some quick math. A typical training session involves 30-50 repetitions. If you’re using commercial training treats at 3-5 calories each, that’s 90-250 extra calories per session. Train twice a day and you could be adding 500 calories on top of your dog’s regular meals.

The Association for Pet Obesity Prevention reports that 59% of dogs in the US are overweight or obese. And here’s the kicker — only about 35% of dog owners even recognize their pet is carrying extra weight. Those daily training treats add up fast, especially for small breeds where 100 extra calories represents a significant chunk of their daily needs.

I made this mistake with my first Golden Retriever. Charlie was a training treat vacuum — so motivated, so eager, so increasingly… round. Our vet finally pointed out that his “training treats” were adding nearly 30% more calories to his diet. The 10% rule (treats should be no more than 10% of daily calories) sounds simple until you realize a 30-pound dog eating 600 calories a day has a treat budget of just 60 calories. That’s maybe 15-20 commercial training treats. For an entire day.

Your Dog’s Daily Kibble as a Training Budget

Think of your dog’s daily food ration as a training budget. A dog eating two cups of kibble per day doesn’t need those two cups dumped in a bowl. That’s 400+ pieces of kibble — each one a potential reward you’re just giving away for free.

Dr. Ian Dunbar puts it bluntly: training treats should not be extra calories and they should not be junk food. Food lures and rewards are part of your dog’s normal daily diet, used periodically during training rather than given all at once at dinner time. He actually tells new puppy owners to stop using food bowls entirely.

The advantage is straightforward. Kibble is complete and balanced nutrition. You’re not supplementing with anything — you’re just changing the delivery method. Zero extra calories. Zero nutritional imbalance. And your dog still gets exactly what they need.

Factor	Commercial Treats	Kibble Training
Extra daily calories	100-500+	0
Cost per month	$15-40	$0 (already bought)
Nutritional balance	Variable	Complete diet
Risk of weight gain	High with frequent training	None
Availability	Need to purchase/carry	Always at home

How to Structure Mealtime Training Sessions

The ‘Nothing in Life Is Free’ Framework

The Nothing in Life Is Free protocol — sometimes called “No Free Lunch” — is about as simple as dog training philosophy gets. Your dog performs a behavior before receiving anything they want. Food, access to the yard, getting their leash clipped on. Everything has a price, and the price is a behavior you choose.

For meal training specifically, this means your dog never gets a bowl of food just placed on the floor. Every piece of kibble is earned. Sit before the first handful. Down for the next. Hold a stay while you count to five, then release. Your dog’s entire breakfast becomes a training session that takes 10-15 minutes instead of the 90 seconds of bowl-inhaling.

I started this with Juno as a 9-week-old puppy. By week three, she was offering sits and eye contact automatically before meals because she’d learned — nothing comes free. It built an incredible foundation that made every future training step easier.

Splitting One Meal Into 3-5 Mini Training Sessions

Here’s the practical structure I use to train dog with food without treats. Take your dog’s morning meal and divide it into small portions in zip-lock bags or small containers.

Session 1 (Morning, 3-5 minutes): Basic obedience warm-up. Sits, downs, hand touches. Use 20% of the meal portion.

Session 2 (Mid-morning, 2-3 minutes): Impulse control work. Wait at doorways, leave-it exercises. Another 20%.

Session 3 (Before a walk, 3 minutes): Leash manners practice. Reward for attention and loose leash position in the house or yard. 20% more.

Session 4 (Afternoon, 5 minutes): New skill introduction or trick training. This gets the biggest share — 30% — because new behaviors need more reinforcement.

Session 5 (Evening wind-down): The remaining 10% goes into a puzzle feeder for quiet mental stimulation.

The beauty of this approach? Your dog stays slightly hungry between sessions, which keeps motivation high. They’re never stuffed and disinterested. They’re never starving and frantic. Just… ready to work.

Using Puzzle Feeders as Training Extensions

Puzzle feeders aren’t just entertainment — they’re training tools that work when you’re busy. A 2019 study found that dogs fed through puzzle toys increased their walking time by 26% and total activity time by 12% compared to bowl feeding. Separate research showed reduced barking and stress behaviors in dogs given food puzzle enrichment.

I rotate between three types:

Kong stuffed with moistened kibble (frozen overnight for longer engagement) — this is straight from Dr. Dunbar’s playbook
Snuffle mats where kibble hides in fabric folds — great for using dog’s kibble for training nose work

Slow-feeder bowls with ridges for the portion that isn’t used in active training

The puzzle feeder handles that last bit of the daily ration while teaching your dog patience, problem-solving, and independent focus. It’s training without you lifting a finger.

Commands to Train at Meal Time

Impulse Control — Wait and Leave It

Meal time is the single best opportunity to build impulse control, and I’ll die on that hill. Your dog wants the food. Desperately. Which makes it the perfect high-motivation scenario.

Wait at the bowl: Hold kibble in your closed fist. Dog noses, paws, mouths at your hand — you do nothing. The instant they back off or look at your face, mark it (“yes!”) and open your hand. This teaches the foundation of all impulse control: backing off gets you what you want.

Progress over a week looks like this:
1. Days 1-2: Reward any moment of stillness
2. Days 3-4: Require 2-3 seconds of calm waiting
3. Days 5-7: Add the “wait” cue, extend to 5-10 seconds
4. Week 2+: Lower the food toward the floor, reward for holding position

Leave it: Place a piece of kibble on the floor, cover it with your hand. When your dog stops trying to get it, reward with a different piece from your other hand. Gradually lift your covering hand. This one took Juno about four days to nail — she was so food-motivated it actually made the learning faster.

Basic Obedience — Sit, Down, Place

Use the meal time training method for dogs to drill these fundamentals with high repetition and zero treat guilt.

Rapid-fire sits: Lure with a piece of kibble above the nose, mark and deliver when the butt hits the floor. Do 10 in a row. Takes about 90 seconds. That’s 10 pieces of kibble well spent.

Down from sit: Slide kibble from nose to floor between the front paws. Most dogs fold into a down. Mark and reward. If your dog pops back up instead — just wait. Don’t repeat the cue. Let them figure it out. The food motivation from using their actual meal makes them more persistent problem-solvers.

Place/bed: Toss a piece of kibble onto their bed or mat. When they step on to get it, mark and reward with another piece. Within one meal, most dogs start going to their place voluntarily. Within a week, you can add duration.

New Trick Introduction (Shape With Kibble)

Shaping — rewarding small steps toward a final behavior — burns through treats fast. That’s exactly why kibble is perfect for it. You can afford 40-50 repetitions per meal without worrying about your dog’s calorie intake.

I shaped Juno’s “spin” trick entirely with breakfast kibble over three mornings:

Morning 1: Rewarded any head turn to the right (15 pieces)
Morning 2: Rewarded only quarter-turns and half-turns (20 pieces)
Morning 3: Rewarded only full rotations, added “spin” cue (20 pieces)

Done. Three breakfasts. One new trick. No training treats purchased.

Making Kibble More Exciting Than Treats

This is where most people mess up the training dog without extra treats approach. They just hold out a piece of boring kibble like it’s supposed to be thrilling. It won’t be — unless you change how you deliver it.

Delivery Method Matters (Toss, Roll, Hide)

The food itself is only half the reward. The other half is how it arrives.

Toss it: Throw kibble so your dog chases it. This adds a prey-drive element that makes plain kibble suddenly exciting. Great for recalls — call your dog, then toss the kibble behind you so they blast past you to catch it.

Roll it: Roll kibble along the floor for your dog to chase. Activates the same chase instinct at lower intensity. Perfect for indoor sessions.
Hide it: Cup kibble in your hands, make your dog search. Or scatter a handful in grass for a “find it” game. The search itself becomes reinforcing.
Rapid delivery: Give five pieces in quick succession for an especially good response. The speed and abundance creates excitement a single treat can’t match.

My Border Collie couldn’t care less about a piece of kibble placed in front of her nose. But roll that same piece of kibble across the kitchen floor? Suddenly it’s the most valuable thing in the universe.

Mixing Kibble With a Tiny Amount of High-Value Food

Here’s a cheat code. Take a zip-lock bag, put your training portion of kibble inside, and add one small piece of cheese or a single freeze-dried liver treat. Seal it. Let it sit for an hour.

The kibble absorbs the scent of the high-value food. To your dog’s nose, every piece now smells like cheese. You’re using one treat’s worth of flavor across 50 pieces of kibble. I call this “scent loading” and it’s genuinely the best trick I’ve ever learned for using dog’s kibble for training stubborn dogs.

You can also try:
– A tiny smear of peanut butter inside the bag
– A splash of low-sodium bone broth mixed into kibble (let it dry)
– Crushing one freeze-dried treat and dusting the kibble

The Premack Principle — Kibble Earns the Good Stuff

The Premack Principle states that a more desirable activity can reinforce a less desirable one. In dog training terms: do the boring thing, and you earn access to the fun thing.

Applied to meal training: your dog performs a behavior for kibble (the work), and after a set number of correct responses, they get access to something they want even more — a short game of tug, permission to go sniff a bush on a walk, or being released to play with another dog.

This flips the script entirely. The kibble isn’t the ultimate reward. The kibble is the ticket to what your dog really wants. And now your dog views working for kibble as a positive thing because it predicts something excellent.

Practical example from my life: Juno does five minutes of heel work for kibble in the morning. Then I release her with “go play!” and she gets to zoom around the yard. She works harder for those five minutes of kibble than she ever did for expensive treats — because she knows what’s coming next.

When This Method Isn’t Enough

I’d be lying if I said kibble training works perfectly for every dog in every situation. It doesn’t.

Low Food Drive Breeds (Adjusting the Approach)

Some breeds just aren’t that into food. Many sighthounds, some terriers, and independent breeds like Shiba Inus or Basenjis can look at a piece of kibble and walk away. If your dog regularly skips meals voluntarily, pure kibble training will be an uphill battle.

Adjustments for lower food drive dogs:

Train before meals, not after. Sounds obvious but timing matters enormously. A slightly hungry dog is a motivated dog.
Use a higher-quality kibble as your training food. Switch from their regular food to a richer formula just for training portions.

Shorten sessions dramatically. Two minutes of engagement is better than five minutes of your dog checking out mentally.
Lean into the Premack Principle. If your dog values play or outdoor access more than food, use kibble as the warm-up act before what they actually want.

And honestly — some dogs just need real treats for certain tasks. That’s fine. The goal isn’t purity. It’s reducing unnecessary treat calories while still getting results.

High-Distraction Environments Still Need High-Value Rewards

Your dog might work beautifully for kibble in your kitchen. Take that same dog to a park full of squirrels and other dogs? Kibble becomes invisible.

This is normal and expected. The training concept of “raising the stakes” means matching your reward value to the difficulty of the environment. At home, kibble works great. In the yard, kibble plus exciting delivery. At the park? You probably need actual high-value treats.

My rule of thumb:

Environment	Distraction Level	Reward Strategy
Inside your home	Low	Plain kibble
Your yard	Low-Medium	Kibble with exciting delivery
Quiet street walk	Medium	Scent-loaded kibble or a few real treats
Dog park or pet store	High	High-value treats (cheese, meat)
Emergency recall	Maximum	Whatever your dog loves most on earth

Use the meal time training method for dogs at home where distractions are low, and save the expensive treats for situations that genuinely demand them. That alone will cut your treat spending by 70-80%.

Frequently Asked Questions

Won’t my dog lose weight if I use their meals for training instead of feeding from a bowl?

No — and this is a common concern. You’re feeding the exact same amount of food. The only change is delivery method. Instead of pouring it in a bowl, you’re handing it out piece by piece. Your dog gets every calorie they need. The only thing that changes is they have to work for it.

What if my dog won’t work for regular kibble?

First, make sure you’re training before meals when they’re actually hungry. If that doesn’t help, try the scent-loading technique — let kibble sit in a bag with a high-value treat to absorb the smell. You can also try switching to a more palatable kibble formula. Some dogs genuinely need a higher-value reward, and that’s okay. Use kibble for easy reps at home and save treats for harder skills.

How young can I start mealtime training with a puppy?

As soon as you bring them home. Dr. Ian Dunbar recommends puppy owners stop using food bowls from day one, stuffing daily food into Kongs and using the rest for training. An 8-week-old puppy can learn to sit for a piece of kibble at their very first meal with you. Keep sessions under two minutes for young puppies and keep expectations simple.

Does this work for multi-dog households?

Yes, but you’ll need to separate dogs during training meals. Each dog gets their own mini sessions in different rooms or at different times. The training works the same way — it’s just logistics that get more complicated. I’ve done this with two dogs and it’s manageable once you establish a routine.

Can I still use this approach if my dog is on a prescription diet?

Absolutely. In fact, it’s even more important because prescription diets are expensive and you definitely don’t want to throw off the nutritional balance with random treats. Use the prescription kibble exactly as directed — just deliver it through training instead of a bowl. Check with your vet first, but most will love this idea.

Mealtime training isn’t some revolutionary hack. It’s common sense that’s been around for decades — Dr. Dunbar, Karen Overall, and countless professional trainers have advocated for it. The real mystery is why more pet owners don’t do it. You’re already buying the food. You’re already feeding your dog twice a day. All you’re doing is making those moments count for something beyond filling a belly. Start tomorrow morning. Measure out breakfast. And make your dog earn every bite. You’ll be genuinely surprised at how fast they learn — and how much less you spend on those little bags of overpriced treats.

Featured Image Source: Pexels